Me? Baines and Kenny are better than Martina?? Coleman obviously is but we havent seen him for a year. Niasse is clearly a bit of a donkey but DCL doesnt even ocupy defenders. Centre halves..... Williams has had more good games than Keane this season though its fashionable on here to blame Williams and Martina for Keane and Baines being shit. Think Gueye is clearly our best defensive midfielder. I just got giddy doing my list
Yes Martina is fucking awful. Can't defend yet some are think he can attack because he floats in a cross which finds an opposition player 99 times out of 100.
Ashley Williams has been a yard dog since he arrived and gifts a golden chance almost every match. Jagielka still has recovery pace and is much less of a liability. Keane has been fine for most of the season.
Everything else you said is fine.