Howard 4 - hesitant throughout and at fault for the goal.
Neville 4 - poor defensively, hoofing a lot and offering little.
Heitinga 5 - not the dominant display I expected.
Distin 6 - some important tackles, worked harder than some.
Baines 6 - tried hard and some good touches.
Pienaar 4 - produced very little and getting sent off put the icing on that.
Fellaini 5 - didn't take control at any point. We will miss him if injured though.
Osman 4 - offered virtually nothing.
Donovan 7 - tried hard, looked interested and made good runs. Wasn't used enough.
Cahill 6 - ran around and unlucky not to score. At least showed passion.
Saha 5 - looked knackered throughout.
Arteta 6 - passing was generally fine but with with no movement from anyone around him he had nowhere to go. Poor set pieces.
Anichebe 5 - full of energy but missing sharpness and should have pulled ball across earlier.
Yak 6 - trying to make a difference despite the fact balls were getting hoofed at him. Good shot and movement. Leading the line well.
Moyes 6 - waited too long to bring on subs but for me they were the right ones. I put the result more down to the players who simply did not perform than him. We should have passed it round this Liverpool team, instead we hit a Liverpool player consistently and let them off.