End of season ratings

[Duncs_a_legend]

Has Barkley banged your missus?

This reminds me of the poster who used to always, ALWAYS give Osman a 5 regardless of how well he played. As in, he would score and get an assist and still be given a 5.

Nope

Check the match day threads, when he's played well I've said so, I've even given him an 8 once and a MOTM

But overall he's been poor.

But I've given him 1 less point that most people have given Baines or Williams or Mirallas, just 1 less point, I even conceded that I could have given him a 6 at a push.
And equal to what a few have put Holgate, who I think actually had an ok season.
It's not like I've given him a 2 or 3, I didn't even say he was our worst player.

Ross has had a poor season, not an ok season or a good season.

[dazfrancis]

Fair enough you have given him praise and MOM in some matches but to say he has been worse than Holgate over the course of the season, or he has contributed less than Barry is wrong.

To say that our most creative player with 8 assists and 5 goals has been worse than Funes Mori or Steklenburg is quite frankly bizarre.

[Bluedylan]

Not starting a new thread for it, but Ossie and Bolasie are on MOTD2 at the moment.

[Audrey Horne]

Ross has had a poor season, not an ok season or a good season.

you are wrong to be honest...

[Bluedylan]

Nope

Check the match day threads, when he's played well I've said so, I've even given him an 8 once and a MOTM

But overall he's been poor.

But I've given him 1 less point that most people have given Baines or Williams or Mirallas, just 1 less point, I even conceded that I could have given him a 6 at a push.
And equal to what a few have put Holgate, who I think actually had an ok season.
It's not like I've given him a 2 or 3, I didn't even say he was our worst player.

Ross has had a poor season, not an ok season or a good season.

My memory could be playing tricks with me, but I'm sure about a month or so ago I gave you a like for saying that he'd had a much better season and that you'd written him off too easily previously.

[Gash]

Ross has had a poor season, not an ok season or a good season.

I've been one of his harshest critics but this is just bollocks.

[Duncs_a_legend]

Fair enough you have given him praise and MOM in some matches but to say he has been worse than Holgate over the course of the season, or he has contributed less than Barry is wrong.

To say that our most creative player with 8 assists and 5 goals has been worse than Funes Mori or Steklenburg is quite frankly bizarre.

Hard to compare against different positions.

Unfair as it is, Barkley has had more chances to show his poor form, so it's hard to mark players down who haven't played much, unless they were awful in the few appearances the made.

Mirallas I think has been ok, not great and not shite.

My opinion is just that out of 10 I would mark Ross a 5 for his contribution to the role he was expected to play. Not a 1 (completely useless) and not 10 (absolute world beater).

[Duncs_a_legend]

you are wrong to be honest...

Nope.

Just an opinion.

[blargins]

Ross has had an ok season.

Let's leave it at that, and move on to better as he leaves us.

[KoemansNumberTens]

There's no barkleys been poor. There's not quite enough special moments and there's still too many utterly careless 1s but he's contributed quite a lot to our good season.
The truth is we've had an awful lot of 7s this season. No one has been dreadful and only a couple have been great

[TheRam]

Nope

Check the match day threads, when he's played well I've said so, I've even given him an 8 once and a MOTM

But overall he's been poor.

But I've given him 1 less point that most people have given Baines or Williams or Mirallas, just 1 less point, I even conceded that I could have given him a 6 at a push.
And equal to what a few have put Holgate, who I think actually had an ok season.
It's not like I've given him a 2 or 3, I didn't even say he was our worst player.

Ross has had a poor season, not an ok season or a good season.

You're never going to like him are you?

I think you know yourself you're chatting complete shite but your dislike of Barkley clouds that judgement.

[TheRam]

Hard to compare against different positions.

Unfair as it is, Barkley has had more chances to show his poor form, so it's hard to mark players down who haven't played much, unless they were awful in the few appearances the made.

Mirallas I think has been ok, not great and not shite.

My opinion is just that out of 10 I would mark Ross a 5 for his contribution to the role he was expected to play. Not a 1 (completely useless) and not 10 (absolute world beater).

And yet you've given Mirallas a 6 who plays a more advunaced role and contributed a lot less.

And given Stek the same rating as Barkley who constantly made mistakes and cost us goals.

[BlueBeagle]

Barkley - 6.5

5 goals isn't a good return for a player in his position. Especially when you factor in the regular mistakes.

[Duncs_a_legend]

You're never going to like him are you?

I think you know yourself you're chatting complete shite but your dislike of Barkley clouds that judgement.

Why would I dislike him?

Because I don't think he's good?

[Bluenose 91]

Still think the maddest shout in here was Funes Mori being our most consistent defender.

Consistently fucking crap maybe.