To be fair, there have been precious few opportunities to judge him since. I think when he's had a run in the team he's largely been pretty effective.
Now we have Gana, Schneiderlin and Davies ahead of him, we're not as reliant on him being fit (just as well) and leaving us with just Barry and McCarthy. I'd like to see him stay this season and see if he can keep himself fit. I really think he'd be a handy option from the bench and particularly on a Sunday against Burnley or in the EL.
If not - because he's injured or doesn't perform - there comes a point where we have to say enough is enough and wish him well for his future away from Everton.