Players we shouldnt have let go

[The Analog Kid]

Yeah that's what I meant

I wasn’t trying to pick holes in your post James!

Didn’t van den Hauwe go to Spurs the same year?


EDIT: Year after, 89.

[Coyb12]

Shane Duffy?! 

Desperate times indeed, the amount of fume when we get linked to the oaf like Ryan Shawcross or similar and yet Shane fucking Duffy, give your head a shake

Is he better than Williams  yep is he better than jags yep is better at centre back than holgate yep.

[Jimmywhack]

I wasn't trying to pick holes in your post James!

Didn't van den Hauwe go to Spurs the same year?


EDIT: Year after, 89.

No
My years around that time are always wrong

[D15TIN]

The duffy posts are doing my head in - no one gave a fuck when he left, he's done well for brighton in the championship, he did well last night hardly a world beater

[Cereal Killer]

Is he better than Williams  yep is he better than jags yep is better at centre back than holgate yep.

Based on what? Marking the mighty Robson-Kanu out the game last night? Doing well in a backs to the wall display? Or a fairly non descript season so far at Brighton who haven't played many top teams yet?

[The Analog Kid]

We let Duffy go cos he was turd at the time, plus when he was here we had the likes of Yobo, Lescott, Jagielka....all playing well and in their prime.


*Actually, I may have fucked up my dates there with all these players..... Distin, not Yobo.

[Cassius]

Is he better than Williams  yep is he better than jags yep is better at centre back than holgate yep.

Let's be honest, I'm better than Williams at the moment.

Jags is better though.

Shane Duffy is not the level we should be looking at. He's at his level.

[ally2]

Richard Dunne was a barrel who makes Ashley Williams look like Margot Fonteyn

[Coyb12]

 

Let's be honest, I'm better than Williams at the moment.

Jags is better though.

Shane Duffy is not the level we should be looking at. He's at his level.

He is a prem centre back,and he would be in front of our 2,jags is finished.

[BlueForYou]

Dunne had a good career that included 80 caps for Ireland

[Cassius]

;DHe is a prem centre back,and he would be in front of our 2,jags is finished.

Yeah, he's now playing in the Prem, for a promoted team, who will be flirting with the relegation places. As I say, he's at his level.

Jags has been finished for three seasons now, hasn't he? Keeps going though and hasn't let us down when he's played.

I know who I'd rather starting for us on Sunday. (It's not Ashley Williams though, that we can agree on).

[BlueForYou]

Billy Kenny was his own mistake

And Liverpool let Dave Watson go!

[BlueForYou]

And Kevin Sheedy!

And Alan Harper!!

And Johnny Morrissey!!!

[Tinga]

Fernandes
Arteta

I always wish we signed Fernandes.

[Coyb12]

Yeah, he's now playing in the Prem, for a promoted team, who will be flirting with the relegation places. As I say, he's at his level.

Jags has been finished for three seasons now, hasn't he? Keeps going though and hasn't let us down when he's played.

I know who I'd rather starting for us on Sunday. (It's not Ashley Williams though, that we can agree on).

As much as I liked jags he should be nowhere the first team,but he is because obviously we have no one better,I'm not talking about jags of 6/7years ago I'm talking about now and Duffy is better In my opinion,I'm not saying he is Maldini,I'm saying he would get in next to Keane.