If Arteta was to manage Newcastle for the next two seasons and he gained successive 7th spot positions, would you then consider him?
To conclude: You are all in agreement that Silva will have a more successful managerial career than Arteta
I don’t think any of us are saying that.
But what most of us are thinking is we are in a bit of turmoil, after three managers in one season, so maybe now wouldn’t be the best time to experiment with a complete managerial novice.
Silva is actually an experienced manager, and has won things, and he has a reputation for being very thorough, and he drills his teams to be fit, energetic, and aggressive.
What do we know about Arteta’s credentials and preferred style?