Which Manager Made The Best/Worst Signings?

[SANA_DR0]

Martinez Season 13/14

Arouna Koné    £6,000,000              
Joel Robles    £2,000,000     
Antolín Alcaraz    Free              
James Mc Carthy    £13,000,000              
Aiden McGeady    £2,500,000              
Jindrich Stanek    Undisclosed

Season Total £23,500,000

Martinez season 14/15

Gareth Barry    £2,000,000                      
Muhamed Bešić    £4,000,000                   
Romelu Lukaku    £28,000,000                   
Brendan Galloway    £4,000,000                 
Samuel Eto'o    Free

Season Total £38,000,000

Martinez Season 15/16

Gerard Deulofeu    £4,300,000              
Tom Cleverley    Free              
Mason Holgate    £500,000                 
Leandro Rodríguez    £500,000                   
Ramiro Funes Mori    £9,500,000                             
Aaron Lennon    £4,500,000                             
Matthew Foulds    £400,000                             
Shani Tarashaj    £3,000,000                             
Oumar Niasse    £13,500,000

Season Total £36,200,000


Martinez over all spend; 97,700,000



Koeman Season 16/17

Maarten Stekelenburg    £1,000,000                   
Idrissa Gueye    £7,100,000              
Ashley Williams    £12,000,000                      
Yannick Bolasie    £25,000,000                   
Ryan Ledson    Undisclosed                   
Ademola Lookman    £7,500,000         
Morgan Schneiderlin    £24,000,000

Season Total £76,600,000

Koeman Season 17/18

Davy Klaassen    £23,600,000                       
Jordan Pickford    £25,000,000                      
Nathangelo Markelo    undisclosed                       
Michael Keane    £25,000,000                   
Sandro    £5,200,000                   
Henry Onyekuru    £7,000,000                       
Wayne Rooney    Free                   
Josh Bowler    £1,500,000                   
Lewis Gibson    £6,000,000                   
Nikola Vlašić    £10,000,000                             
Boris Mathis    Free                             
Cuco Martina    Free                             
Gylfi Sigurdsson    £45,000,000                             
Nikola Vlasic    £10,000,000                             
Dennis Adeniran    undisclosed


Season Total; £158,300,000

Koeman overall spend; 234,900,000


From this season, I have to say Schneiderlin/Williams/Martina have been shocking.
compare them to Martinez's players who got a lot of stick Funes Mori, McCarthy, Kone..

thoughts?

[Jimmywhack]

Martinez

[SANA_DR0]

Martinez

did he make the better signings, or the more poorer signings? compared to Koeman?

[Jimmywhack]

did he make the better signings, or the more poorer signings? compared to Koeman?

There is more trash on Martinez list

[Macca77]

Walter Smith

[Waltzer]

You cant really compare based on costs as the 13/14 season is light years away from the 17/18 season. That Kone 6 million is probably 15-20 million in this close season

[SANA_DR0]

You cant really compare based on costs as the 13/14 season is light years away from the 17/18 season. That Kone 6 million is probably 15-20 million in this close season

ive put the trasnfer fee's up, but they dont mean much, i meant on quality of the players brought in.

[Lazarou]

Like any a manager a mixed bag. Lukaku the best signing of the lot and we signed him twice. How much influence Martinez had on that is hard to say.

[GrantyBoy78]

I very much doubt Martinez knew anything about a young defender on the fringes of the first team at Barnsley. So not fair to credit him with that one.

[Ell Capitan]

Martinez signings were shite by comparison.

Lots of decent players bought by Koeman, some the jury is out. But many have a proven track record and we won't see the quality until the team is more settled and playing better.

[kramer0]

Say all you like about the potential we've bought recently and how it might pay off in the near future but the fact that we have nobody peaking right now shows you how crap our business has been.

And that's before you get into fit. Funes Mori and Niasse for a team that wants to play possession football? I don't even need to say anything about what we did this summer.

We are bad at transfers. It's the biggest reason why we're now also bad at football.

[School of Science]

Mike Arteta, Tim Cahill, Yakubu, Lescott, Distin, Pienaar and Fellaini. ( I won't mention Coleman and Baines in that group ) How many of those players would just walk into this present team ?

[kramer0]

Mike Arteta, Tim Cahill, Yakubu, Lescott, Distin, Pienaar and Fellaini. ( I won't mention Coleman and Baines in that group ) How many of those players would just walk into this present team ?

What Koeman would have a given for a Fellaini.

A long-ball manager's wet dream.

[Heisenberg]

Hard to compare really because it's the manager himself who is tasked to get the most out of players . Moyes signed nobodies and got the best out of them. Koeman bought brilliant players but got nothing out of them. So on that premise I think it's difficult to judge things like this

[The Analog Kid]

What Koeman would have a given for a Fellaini.

A long-ball manager's wet dream.

I think we miss him. Just my opinion like.