I tend to have more (max/peak) pleasure from a blistering counterattack (Leicester 15/16 and Mourinho's teams) than I do from a more deliberate style of play (e.g. Guardiola).
I don't think it's contrarian to think that either. As @GLewis
said, we probably struggle to remember the majority of the match. Many will probably get more pleasure overall from typical Guardiola, but I prefer the raw athleticism allayed with skill of direct football.
That's not to say that Guardiola teams can't do that, they do, but it's not what I would associate them with.