Schneiderlin

[EVERTON 66]

Do not know. Unlike some other cast offs from Man Utd he came with a good reputation. Once again if Sam and his team can find a role for him in the squad and he is happy to stay as a squad member then keep him. Just do not play him and Gueye together.

My sentiments exactly he is still a good player n y can't we b like the other top teams n keep 2vgood players 4 every position makes sense. There will times suspensions n injuries  will amount so keeping him makes practical sense. As 4 the other midfielders besic should move on McCarthy is always injured Barclay doesn't intend staying n banigame is still raw!!!!

[therealdunc]

He is over rated

Looked good in an average Southampton team

Found out at Man United

Everton claim they want to be challenging with the likes of United, but that won’t be happening if we sign their cast offs and rejects

Time to get rid and move on

[sam of the south]

Je Suis Concombre 🥒✊🏼

[Rodenplav64]

He is over rated

Looked good in an average Southampton team

Found out at Man United

Everton claim they want to be challenging with the likes of United, but that won’t be happening if we sign their cast offs and rejects

Time to get rid and move on

I am just glad City didn't mind signing Chelseas cast off in De Bruyne or us signing Chelseas cast off in Lukaku or Liverpool signing Chelseas cast off in Salah or ............................. ..... never mind I am sure their are cast offs the League over .

[Lxxx]

He is over rated

Looked good in an average Southampton team

Found out at Man United

Everton claim they want to be challenging with the likes of United, but that won’t be happening if we sign their cast offs and rejects

Time to get rid and move on

Lots of good players move on from big clubs when it hasn't worked out. The key is to work out whether you're signing a player hungry to prove them wrong or one that has lost that desire and feels that anything else but a big club is a step down. I think we've signed the latter whereas there are plenty of examples of the former. It all just brings sharply into focus the due diligence we do/have done on our recruitment.

[Silas]

Koeman really did a number on this team really. Remember when people were using terms like Rolls Royce for Schneiderlin?

[therealdunc]

I am just glad City didn't mind signing Chelseas cast off in De Bruyne or us signing Chelseas cast off in Lukaku or Liverpool signing Chelseas cast off in Salah or ............................. ..... never mind I am sure their are cast offs the League over .

All 3 examples when to other clubs and proved themselves

The end

[Rodenplav64]

All 3 examples when to other clubs and proved themselves

The end

All 3 considered cast offs . The End .

By the way is our Manager a cast off ?

[therealdunc]

All proved themselves at other clubs before getting a big move

[brap2]

Koeman really did a number on this team really. Remember when people were using terms like Rolls Royce for Schneiderlin?

The stats backed it up, he was playing extremely well. He is a talented player, that isn’t up for debate imo.

[Ross]

Interestingly he’s now played exactly the same amount of matches and minutes (bar 10 less) to last season with us and his defensive stats are better this season than last.

I doubt anyone would suggest he’s playing better this season though.

[blargins]

All 3 examples when to other clubs and proved themselves

The end

All three players were quite young as well.

We normally buy Utd players when they're in their prime and not likely to get any better. In other words, their cast offs. Maybe only Howard was a player who improved when he came to us.

[therealdunc]

All three players were quite young as well.

We normally buy Utd players when they're in their prime and not likely to get any better. In other words, their cast offs. Maybe only Howard was a player who improved when he came to us.

Exactly

We had a long history under Moyes of buying United cast offs

We need to move on from buying their rubbish like Phil Neville and start competing with them for their transfer targets.
Likewise selling them our best player in the summer won’t help close the gap, but only increase it.

[Lxxx]

Exactly

We had a long history under Moyes of buying United cast offs

We need to move on from buying their rubbish like Phil Neville and start competing with them for their transfer targets.
Likewise selling them our best player in the summer won’t help close the gap, but only increase it.

Got no problem with selling clubs like Man U/City our best players for top money, as long as we have a recruitment strategy in place to spend it wisely and find the next gem.

[Major Clanger]

We need to move on from buying their rubbish like Phil Neville and start competing with them for their transfer targets.

How?