Mccarthy is shite
Hes not really though is he.
When hes fit I actually think he is half decent.
He is incredibly limited in what he does with the ball granted but you have to think what role Silva wants him to play.
In a pressing style I think he could do ok.
In the derby that time at Goodison when Mane scored in the 209th minute, before McCarthy went off injured I felt we where doing well because he was one of the very few who actually bothered pressing their players.
I wouldn't be arsed if he was sold like don't get me wrong but I think it's harsh to call him shite.
The last manager who tried at least to get at least some form of an attacking game going was Martinez and in his first season McCarthy was one of the key players, he may be under Silva although I highly doubt it.
Hes not gonna be sold due to the extent of his injury anyway so we will see what happens when he returns.