Said it for a while.
If he wasn't scouse or an Evertonian not many would care that much for him. The fact he was "one of our own" clouded many of his average performances for us.
A good goal against Newcastle and a brief purple patch in Martinez first season wasn't enough to convince me.
Hasn't got the mentality to be a top player, he will realise soon that the grass isn't always greener, as did Rodwell.
Only regret is that we never got £35M for him instead of £15M.