Should we sack Steve Walsh?

[Duncs_a_legend]

I wonder what Walsh's signings would go for now, just to see how much if a disaster it's been.
Lookman, DCL and Gueye probably make up a lot as they're likely to be worth much more than what we paid for them.
My estimates are probably well out and I've probably missed a few, but its an interesting debate.

Bolasie (when fit) - £15m?
Williams - £8m
Gueye - £25m?
DCL - £20m?
Schneiderlin - £20m
Lookman - £25m
Sig - £30m?
Keane - £20m
Pickford - £40m
Klaassen - £18m
Vlasic - £20m
Sandro - £15m
Martina - £8m
Rooney - n/a
Theo - £20m
Tosun - 15m?

Onyekuru - £10m (haven't got a clue)

Total - £309m

[Jimmywhack]

Some of them prices are way wide of the mark

[Duncs_a_legend]

Some of them prices are way wide of the mark

I know, I said that in the post.

Wide as in too high or too low?
And which ones?

[Jimmywhack]

I know, I said that in the post.

Wide as in too high or too low?
And which ones?

Martina and Williams stood out tbh
Id say you've over valued a few

[Lxxx]

I wonder what Walsh's signings would go for now, just to see how much if a disaster it's been.
Lookman, DCL and Gueye probably make up a lot as they're likely to be worth much more than what we paid for them.
My estimates are probably well out and I've probably missed a few, but its an interesting debate.

Bolasie (when fit) - £15m?
Williams - £8m
Gueye - £25m?
DCL - £20m?
Schneiderlin - £20m
Lookman - £25m
Sig - £30m?
Keane - £20m
Pickford - £40m
Klaassen - £18m
Vlasic - £20m
Sandro - £15m
Martina - £8m
Rooney - n/a
Theo - £20m
Tosun - 15m?

Onyekuru - £10m (haven't got a clue)

Total - £309m

If you are trying to make the point I think you're trying to make, it's not working.

[brap2]

Keanes pony isn’t he?

Wouldn’t mind seeing him next to a good cb rather than a procession of past it fellas who need to retire and total walking disasters like, but very unconvinced.

[dunkster]

I think only walcott and pickford look about right on that list. Waaaaay too optimistic on all the rest

[Duncs_a_legend]

If you are trying to make the point I think you're trying to make, it's not working.

No point really. Just from an economical point of view it's not like we've flushed £200m down the drain, mainly because of how the transfer market has blew up over the past 18 months.

We've also benefited from getting in a few young British players in before the market went daft.
Keane for example would still go for around £20m, even though he's been written off by many (I personally like Keane)

I do think Walsh should go though, and getting our money back should never be one of his main priorities. The players bought in haven't cut it, and most of them aren't worth what we paid.

[brap2]

One point on the transfer window inflation - we must be the only bloody club in the country who’s players values have plummeted in the last 18 months. Every other fucker is worth £30m+ these days.

[GrantyBoy78]

Keanes pony isn't he?

Wouldn't mind seeing him next to a good cb rather than a procession of past it fellas who need to retire and total walking disasters like, but very unconvinced.

Agree; for that fee you’d want him to be ‘the main bloke’ but it looks like we can only hope he grows into the ‘bloke next to the main bloke’.

[brap2]

Agree; for that fee you’d want him to be ‘the main bloke’ but it looks like we can only hope he grows into the ‘bloke next to the main bloke’.

If that!

[TheRam]

Not convinced by Keane at all but there's very small signs of improvement.

[Lxxx]

Not convinced by Keane at all but there's very small signs of improvement.

Or were, until Sam threw him under the bus last night with his comments. For a lad with apparently fragile confidence probably not best to level a defeat at him.

[gizzblue]

Or were, until Sam threw him under the bus last night with his comments. For a lad with apparently fragile confidence probably not best to level a defeat at him.

But this is Sam's main m.o. it's everyone's fault but his ....is it any wonder our youngsters want away from his cancerous attitude.

[Shogun]

Keane is alright until he’s pulled out wide and then he gets burned for pace.