Michael Keane

[brap2]

Not his biggest fan but when he's good he's good.

[blueToffee]

Up in the air to me as to whether he's a squad player or a first team player, but under Ancelotti (and in fairness under Ferguson too) he's looking a lot more like a reliable first team player.

Either way, I like him and I'd keep him.

[ajax_andy]

Really good last night, him and Holgate look like a good partnership.  Maybe another whose starting to turn a corner with us.

[TheRam]

Meh, first game back he gives the ball away in his own half within the first five minutes.

Yesterday it took him three minutes to do that.

He will always have that in him unfortunately. I can’t wait to get him out the team for Yerry.

[GrantyBoy78]

2 years left on his deal. Decision time: needs to be offered a new deal or sold.


Sent from my iPhone using NSNO Everton Forums

[ajax_andy]

Meh, first game back he gives the ball away in his own half within the first five minutes.

Yesterday it took him three minutes to do that.

He will always have that in him unfortunately. I can’t wait to get him out the team for Yerry.

Kean (man of the match and scorer of the only goal) - shit, get him out.

Keane - Garbage, did nothing good again... Apparently decent game.

Starting to question your judgement tbh!

[Waltzer]

2 years left on his deal. Decision time: needs to be offered a new deal or sold.


Sent from my iPhone using NSNO Everton Forums

Id sale. We need to start being more savvy and selling when we can hopefully make a profit. His stock is reasonably high at the moment, but us fans who watch him know he has a number of errors in him and probably wont be what we need. I personally thought him and Holgate weren't that great yesterday and when Buendia and Pukki came on they got pulled all over the place. It was easy before against a reserve Norwich side

[sam of the south]

Kean (man of the match and scorer of the only goal) - shit, get him out.

Keane - Garbage, did nothing good again... Apparently decent game.

Starting to question your judgement tbh!

Think you might wanna edit your spellings, mate.

[TheRam]

Kean (man of the match and scorer of the only goal) - shit, get him out.

Keane - Garbage, did nothing good again... Apparently decent game.

Starting to question your judgement tbh!

Question it if you like but I’m not making judgements on one game of football that isn’t really proper football.

[KoemansNumberTens]

Question it if you like but I’m not making judgements on one game of football that isn’t really proper football.

I think the problem is your judgement on that 1 game is based in part on your long term judgement of the players

Keane was good. Kean wasn’t. Yet because people think it opposite might be true in terms of long term usefulness they rate them using different scales

[Cozzie]

Still rather sell him.

Doesn't do it often enough, runs a little weird and just isn't what we need.

New CB is needed.

[GrantyBoy78]

The issue might be in this deflated market, no one would be able to offer decent money for him? Would you still sell if we could only get £10m for him?


Sent from my iPhone using NSNO Everton Forums

[bigmanbob]

Think he was ok yesterday but was surprised he was MOM, purely based on his second half performance I'd have given it to Iwobi

[blargins]

Keep him until we get better. With our track record of selling first and taking 6 years to replace having Keane is much better than not having anyone.


Sent from my iPhone using NSNO Everton Forums

[Bluedylan]

Sell him, if you get any remotely reasonable bid.

Not a fan, and one swallow doesn't make a summer.