Coleman Lescott Stones Baines
Kanchelskis Arteta Fellaini Pienaar
Can't improve much on that team - Controversial call, but I would add Stones at the back instead of Jags. I think he has already surpassed Jags at his peak, and you could see his ability as soon as he came in the team. Although Stones was young and played no where near as much as Jags, I think he is the better player.
Very similar situation with Rooney - Cahill played more for us and did a fantastic job, but a prime Rooney beats him.