Totally get your point but surely we need to see some signs of progression which haven't been there for me.
Most managers don't need to change 11 players before being able to implement a half decent playing style and I think it's unreasonable to suggest people are losing their heads unneccessarily- we 've been shit for ages and it's getting worse.
Let's not forget that 5 of the starting 11 have been signed under him with his 2nd most expensive signing also being on the bench so we can't absolve him of any responsibility.
Truth is we do not look any better than last year despite the influx of what look like decent players.
I'm not saying he shouldn't shoulder any of the blame, far from it. Of course he should. I just think his hands are tied by not having the type of players he prefers, particularly in midfield.
As much as I love gueye, his deficiencies with the ball are glaring. As much as I like siggy, he hinders the team.
Hate to use them as an example of how to set up but Liverpool are prime modern day team. Can say the same for City and to an extent Spurs. You nee the midfield 3 to be extremely comfy on the ball, and gomes aside, we don't have anyone who is (sig just isn't involved enough).
I think Silva gets a pass to a certain extent because he hasn't got the tools to carry out his gameplan. Yeah sure, there's arguments he should adapt and change tactic to suit the team. But in my opinion if you go out for him and are backing him you've got to back him further. Pep at City is prime example, he never changed his tactic and was well off the pace with half a team that was unable to carry out his plan. Klopp the same for that matter.
Agree, he should not be above criticism but let's not get carried away. I have seen progress, particularly in the games against the big 6. The only thing that stops us getting more points in them games is daft mistakes or maybe a weak mentality that has been at the club far longer than Silva has.
I'll be honest, if I could go back to any appointment under moshiri and redo it, it would be koeman. The glaring obvious choice was bringing in monchi and aiming for emery, but that was a tad too far at that point.
Still have faith in Silva, and reckon he will get a tune out of our very promising youngsters