Best players to win nothing

[blargins]

I think Martyn would beat Howard.

[74Blue]

I think Martyn would beat Howard.

Absolutely. That's not even debatable.

[SANA_DR0]

A prime Yakubu or a prime Lukaku? I loved the Yak

mmm this posts makes me want to go find a Yak and try its prime.

[D15TIN]

               Howard
 Coleman Lescott Stones Baines
Kanchelskis Arteta Fellaini Pienaar
               Rooney 
               Lukaku

Can't improve much on that team - Controversial call, but I would add Stones at the back instead of Jags. I think he has already surpassed Jags at his peak, and you could see his ability as soon as he came in the team. Although Stones was young and played no where near as much as Jags, I think he is the better player.

Very similar situation with Rooney - Cahill played more for us and did a fantastic job, but a prime Rooney beats him.

a prime martyn shits on tim howard

[KoemansNumberTens]

Wins the lot in its prime that team.

Although I'm always having Joey Yobo over Lescott.

I remember yobos first 10 or so games. He genuinely looked like he might be the best defender in the world. Got sent off against Newcastle and came back from the suspension half the player

[eyesalwaysblue]

George Wood, Duncan Mcenzie, Martin Dobson, Dave Thomas, Andy King,Mark Higgins,Bob Latchford,Imre Varadi,Adrian Heath...an old mans list....

[boothill]

                  martyn
          yobo  jags  distin
                 carsley
coleman  speed arteta  baines
                  kanchelskis
                    rooney
 

[Brownie20]

George Wood, Duncan Mcenzie, Martin Dobson, Dave Thomas, Andy King,Mark Higgins,Bob Latchford,Imre Varadi,Adrian Heath...an old mans list....

Umm pretty sure Inchy won a couple of trophies with us

[eyesalwaysblue]

Maybe he was later than i thought

[Optimistic Blue]

....................Ruddy
Heitinga...Materazzi....Musta fi....Valente
................Dier....Dacou rt
Donovan........Manny........S handy Andy
.....................Eto'o

[The Analog Kid]

Linekar?

[Kev0312]

a prime martyn shits on tim howard

Had southall in 95. Might be through blue tinted specs but think he is the best I have ever seen when he was in his prime.

[irishtoffee]

Had southall in 95. Might be through blue tinted specs but think he is the best I have ever seen when he was in his prime.

Of course, but it's only players who won nothing with us. I actually meant the peak of their Everton careers which is why I didn't include Rooney. I didn't make that clear at the start though. I think I'd take lescott or distin over yobo. I never really took to him.

[Tony Clifton]

No love for Richard Gough here?  I'd have him alongside Lescott.

....................Ruddy
Heitinga...Materazzi....Musta fi....Valente
................Dier....Dacou rt
Donovan........Manny........S handy Andy
.....................Eto'o

Valente?  Naaahhhh 

Drenthe and Ferrari on the bench? 

Anyway, here's my madness:

Martyn
Coleman Gough Lescott Baines
Carsley
Kanchelskis Arteta Pienaar
      Rooney 
    Lukaku

Bench from:
Howard
Barkley
Jagielka
Yak
Campbell
Stones
Yobo

...
Struggling now, especially for left back cover
...
tempted to throw a few more number tens in
...
I reckon Fernandes could have done a job at left back. 
...
I quit.

[JordanianEmbassy]

Linekar?

Since 95