If there was a highlights reel of my playing career, admittedly Saturday league but at a decent standard, I reckon I'd look pretty decent in a nice montage and might get a trial out of it based on the best of my best bits. Truth is I was a bit shit really compared to a lot of my peers but you get my point....
Absolutely - hence the first line in my post "Funes Mori - he's shit hot on YouTube like!" being very tongue in cheek.
The point is he lies somewhere in between. He has the ability to play well and he has the ability to lose us a game. What he doesn't have is the consistency needed for us to say how good he is and some of us think that means he's shit and some of us think we need to see more of of him.
It's too easy to say 'shit' or 'decent'.