Sorry but that's nonsense. You can't debate the value of a signing if you don't factor in cost
Andy Carroll was a bad buy because they paid 35m for him. If they'd got him for 500k the same player would have been a fantastic buy
But again does value really matter to anyone on here
.. when it's sweet fuck all to do with any of us in reality.
He's either good enough 'go get him' or shite 'don't bother' ..... especially in the ever increasing mad hatters tea party figures being bandied about for players and the wages lately .