Nah. I'll stretch to 'effective on his best day', but not good or anything like that.
If we're comparing him to players who play for better teams than us then you wouldn't say he was good. For a mid table side he probably averages a goal or assist more or less every other game, which by any metric is pretty good.
I get what you're saying but at some stage the lad does deserve some credit. He doesn't get cut enough slack because he's unorthodox.