Much like the players that inspired you, but players that you just never took to. The likes of Martina and Alcaraz are obvious ones. Maybe players who you didn't like but other people did - some people at least.
Mine are, in no particular order
Norman Whiteside - never forgave him for that goal on 1985
Gary Naysmith - just really offended me that he made a living out of Everton.
Pat Nevin - I just didn't like him and thought he was far too lightweight.
Mike Newell - he just didn't fit the bill of an Everton striker for me
Peter Beardsley - just didn't like him
Hold up. No-one said Everton players. Yet everyone has gone "Five players I never liked? Not sure I can narrow it down to just five, but I'll do my best" And they're ALL Blues!
Anyway, mine are:
And that's only because I can't put Pembridge 5 times!
(Surprised no-one has put Sandy Brown yet)