1. Davy Klaassen - Just the biggest disappointment in terms of expectations for me, was really excited when we signed him as well.
2. James McFadden - Always like to see a Scottish player do well for Everton but unfortunately he seemed to be better at international football than club football.
3. Andy van der Meyde - When I heard we were signing a Dutch international from Inter Milan I thought he would be awesome. Despite the drinks and drugs and Moyes fallouts I had a glimmer of hope he would turn things around but when Moyes continued preferring playing others like Dan Gosling out of position on the wing then I knew all was lost.
4. James Vaughan - Seemed to be very promising and even got a start against Arsenal where we ended up winning the game. Shame about injuries, he never really got any momentum.
5. Jose Baxter - Had a reputation of being as good a goalscorer as Rooney at youth level and even made a couple of appearances for the first team at the age of 16. A real shame he was hanging out with a bad crowd and he just became a player just to make up the numbers on the bench while Moyes would prefer making defensive subs anyway.