Jarrad Branthwaite

This is the new NSNO Everton forum to discuss the Mighty Blues
Kerryblueboy
Posts: 2503
Karma: 689

Re: Jarrad Branthwaite

Post

A small procedure 5 weeks ago still no sign my spidey senses are tingling here
AjaxAndy
Posts: 4820
Karma: 2189

Re: Jarrad Branthwaite

Post

sam of the south wrote: Sat Aug 24, 2024 3:06 pm I don’t think doing it late in the window would be doing it right, particularly as Dyche isn’t playing our new cb over Keane, plus Beto is a bit poo, Chermiti is injured, and Maupay is a twat.
I don't think keeping him is the right option if a bid comes in either judging by what I just watched today. Rock and a hard place!
sam of the south
Posts: 1925
Karma: 1489

Re: Jarrad Branthwaite

Post

AjaxAndy wrote: Sat Aug 24, 2024 4:46 pm I don't think keeping him is the right option if a bid comes in either judging by what I just watched today. Rock and a hard place!
I see what you’re saying, but he can come good, maybe? 😬 (I know that he only really hit a purple patch in those first few weeks under Ancelotti, but I’m clinging onto it)

*talking about DCL here btw, obvs
AjaxAndy
Posts: 4820
Karma: 2189

Re: Jarrad Branthwaite

Post

sam of the south wrote: Sat Aug 24, 2024 4:48 pm I see what you’re saying, but he can come good, maybe? 😬 (I know that he only really hit a purple patch in those first few weeks under Ancelotti, but I’m clinging onto it)

*talking about DCL here btw, obvs
Oh yeah I'd keep DCL if he'd sign a new deal, I don't think he will though and if a decent bid comes in we have to sell.

I'd rather he signed an extension though.
Dchans
Posts: 555
Karma: 173

Re: Jarrad Branthwaite

Post

Time to cash in and reinvest before we get relegated??

Not the preferred option but might be the most sensible given the first two games
Audrey Horne
User avatar
Posts: 6125
Location: 53.4389° N - 2.9662° W
Karma: 2519

Re: Jarrad Branthwaite

Post

Eh???
TheRam
Posts: 6352
Karma: 6491

Re: Jarrad Branthwaite

Post

Half of it will go straight into the club.

5 days to sign who and what, with around £30m if we’re lucky?

We’d be a worse team most probably.
Bluebridge
Posts: 1605
Karma: 883

Re: Jarrad Branthwaite

Post

Dchans wrote: Sun Aug 25, 2024 6:31 am Time to cash in and reinvest before we get relegated??

Not the preferred option but might be the most sensible given the first two games
Given the first two games, then the most sensible option is to keep him and get him back in the side.
Toddacelli
User avatar
Posts: 1826
Karma: 1866

Re: Jarrad Branthwaite

Post

We have a very, very, short list of genuine top half PL players and Branthwaite is one of them. Selling him this week and rolling the dice on replacing him without losing quality in the side is just about as risky a strategy as you can get.

What we would need to happen is another youngster like him comes in on low wages because we can’t afford established PL defender wages. So the ‘new JB’ would not only have to come in untested but also have to perform as well and get up to speed immediately.

Just not going to happen is it? Keep the lad, have a great season with us and sell him for £200M in the summer.
AjaxAndy
Posts: 4820
Karma: 2189

Re: Jarrad Branthwaite

Post

Toddacelli wrote: Sun Aug 25, 2024 9:12 am We have a very, very, short list of genuine top half PL players and Branthwaite is one of them. Selling him this week and rolling the dice on replacing him without losing quality in the side is just about as risky a strategy as you can get.

What we would need to happen is another youngster like him comes in on low wages because we can’t afford established PL defender wages. So the ‘new JB’ would not only have to come in untested but also have to perform as well and get up to speed immediately.

Just not going to happen is it? Keep the lad, have a great season with us and sell him for £200M in the summer.
I think we'd be much stronger with getting a competent CB, an actual RB and a backup LB than we'd be keeping Jarrod personally.

I don't think you need to even be all that great to be a solid CB in a Dyche side, just have the basics and a decent mentality.

We can't just cling on to Branthwaite because he's had one good season under Dyche, there's every chance we could replicate that with a new player or JOB given how CBs tend to excel under this manager.
Bob Sacamano
User avatar
Posts: 1606
Karma: 847

Re: Jarrad Branthwaite

Post

Keep him imo. Before JB came into the team Tarkowski was looking like a championship clogger. Since Branthwaite has been injured surprise surprise he’s looking like a championship clogger. Keane is shite and we can bring in Mina for his 12 games a season to get us out of jail.
brap2
Posts: 4370
Karma: 4089

Re: Jarrad Branthwaite

Post

Yeah I would like to see him back in the team now please.

If onanas replacement was £10m ffp job Tim, then god knows who this kids replacement would be.
Gash
Posts: 5957
Location: Dumfries and Galloway
Karma: 3905

Re: Jarrad Branthwaite

Post

Apart from some dodgy Liverpool stories there's not been anything linking him with a move other than the Utd bids. It would take a crazy offer for us to sell this late in the window and anyone interested will know that. He's not pushing for a move and by all accounts is happy here.

I'm confident he'll be here this season.
Bluebridge
Posts: 1605
Karma: 883

Re: Jarrad Branthwaite

Post

AjaxAndy wrote: Sun Aug 25, 2024 9:40 am I think we'd be much stronger with getting a competent CB, an actual RB and a backup LB than we'd be keeping Jarrod personally.

I don't think you need to even be all that great to be a solid CB in a Dyche side, just have the basics and a decent mentality.

We can't just cling on to Branthwaite because he's had one good season under Dyche, there's every chance we could replicate that with a new player or JOB given how CBs tend to excel under this manager.
All well and good if the money we get goes on new players, but with the takeover not happening before the next window, then I’d imagine the money we get would be used to “keep the lights on” over the winter.
AjaxAndy
Posts: 4820
Karma: 2189

Re: Jarrad Branthwaite

Post

Bluebridge wrote: Sun Aug 25, 2024 11:06 am All well and good if the money we get goes on new players, but with the takeover not happening before the next window, then I’d imagine the money we get would be used to “keep the lights on” over the winter.
Yeah definitely only advocating selling to improve the squad otherwise there'd be absolutely no benefit
Post Reply Previous topicNext topic