Financial Fairplay Investigation - 2025 Nobody in Breach

This is the new NSNO Everton forum to discuss the Mighty Blues

What is the lowest amount of points you would feel content with receiving back from the appeal?

0
3
5%
1-3
4
7%
4-6
31
53%
7-9
6
10%
10
15
25%
 
Total votes: 59

Cereal Killer
Posts: 2570
Karma: 870

Re: Financial Fairplay Investigation - Further 2 points deducted.

Post

So if we sell a 99% stake in all our assets to, let’s call them Blue Dell Loophole Ltd based in Panama, for £400m with £350m upfront.

The other £50m is due 6 months later which if they don’t pay, ownership reverts fully to Everton FC

Blue Dell Loophole Ltd then ceases trading so payment can’t be made, we get everything back, £350m and our FFP worries are no more

All legit and completey allowed by the PL
Toddacelli
User avatar
Posts: 1826
Karma: 1866

Re: Financial Fairplay Investigation - Further 2 points deducted.

Post

brap2 wrote: Fri Jun 07, 2024 10:48 am Just to note the prem tried to close the loophole, the clubs voted not to in a majority.

Most likely we were one of the clubs voting not to.

I know your point, bud. You and a couple of others have been consistent in reminding us that ‘he who is without sin..’ and all that. It doesn’t absolve the people running the Premier League from letting it become what it is.

I would also point out that this is not us as one bad apple spoiling the barrel. This is us in a rotten system, stooping to their level, because it is the only way to compete in a system like this. Not that the choice to do it wasn’t ours, but that the choices given to us were theirs and they still fucked us for doing it.

I agree with you about what we both want for our club, but the reality is we’re all in the mud wrestling with pigs. Saying that it would be nicer if we hadn’t got in doesn’t really help because that’s where the game is now - right in the shit.
Cods
User avatar
Posts: 2439
Location: 33°51'06.5"S 151°13'06.6"E
Karma: 800

Re: Financial Fairplay Investigation - Further 2 points deducted.

Post

Toddacelli wrote: Sat Jun 08, 2024 7:18 am I would also point out that this is not us as one bad apple spoiling the barrel. This is us in a rotten system, stooping to their level, because it is the only way to compete in a system like this.
Very much this, and that it's likely we're a bit shitty that we used to be in there, part of the big 5 EPL promoters, and now they're having a party without us, joined by a couple of former no-marks in our place.
74Blue
Posts: 591
Karma: 346

Re: Financial Fairplay Investigation - Further 2 points deducted.

Post

What would stop a club selling an asset to a subsidiary for £500m, then the subsidiary selling it baxk to the club 6 months later for £1. As soon as they start getting cloae to their PSR limit, just repeat the process.

Morally,it stinks, but there's nothing in the rules to stop them.
777Kidnappings
Posts: 3015
Karma: 1687

Re: Financial Fairplay Investigation - Further 2 points deducted.

Post

74Blue wrote: Sat Jun 08, 2024 7:01 pm What would stop a club selling an asset to a subsidiary for £500m, then the subsidiary selling it baxk to the club 6 months later for £1. As soon as they start getting cloae to their PSR limit, just repeat the process.

Morally,it stinks, but there's nothing in the rules to stop them.
I think it has to be fair market value. Apparently though Chelsea have sold the hotel but someone still retain the income from it. Which is where it becomes a farce

What's to stop a team building infrastructure to sell. Could Newcastle just build a load of houses or even other clubs stadiums to get round ffp
superpull
Posts: 1325
Karma: 1131

Re: Financial Fairplay Investigation - Further 2 points deducted.

Post

Chelsea have done the equivalent of us selling the stadium to these guys

They're an external company, but the stadium doesn't really leave our possession.
brap2
Posts: 4373
Karma: 4093

Re: Financial Fairplay Investigation - Further 2 points deducted.

Post

777Kidnappings wrote: Sat Jun 08, 2024 7:24 pm I think it has to be fair market value. Apparently though Chelsea have sold the hotel but someone still retain the income from it. Which is where it becomes a farce

What's to stop a team building infrastructure to sell. Could Newcastle just build a load of houses or even other clubs stadiums to get round ffp
Nothing massively new, other than that they sold it to themselves.

https://www.bbc.com/news/business-11403202

Abramovic used to buy a season ticket at Chelsea for £1m a season!
Cozzie
User avatar
Posts: 6093
Location: Wherever I lay my hat
Karma: 2391

Re: Financial Fairplay Investigation - Further 2 points deducted.

Post

Cozzie
User avatar
Posts: 6093
Location: Wherever I lay my hat
Karma: 2391

Re: Financial Fairplay Investigation - Further 2 points deducted.

Post

Haven't heard or seen of anything similar about us yet.

Will be interesting to know whether or not we ourselves have to raise before the 1st of July or not, if at all. You'd think there would be murmurings of it by now.
777Kidnappings
Posts: 3015
Karma: 1687

Re: Financial Fairplay Investigation - Further 2 points deducted.

Post

Villa apparently considering legal action against the premier league now too
brap2
Posts: 4373
Karma: 4093

Re: Financial Fairplay Investigation - Further 2 points deducted.

Post

Toddacelli wrote: Sat Jun 08, 2024 7:18 am I know your point, bud. You and a couple of others have been consistent in reminding us that ‘he who is without sin..’ and all that. It doesn’t absolve the people running the Premier League from letting it become what it is.

I would also point out that this is not us as one bad apple spoiling the barrel. This is us in a rotten system, stooping to their level, because it is the only way to compete in a system like this. Not that the choice to do it wasn’t ours, but that the choices given to us were theirs and they still fucked us for doing it.

I agree with you about what we both want for our club, but the reality is we’re all in the mud wrestling with pigs. Saying that it would be nicer if we hadn’t got in doesn’t really help because that’s where the game is now - right in the shit.
Yeah but specifically in this case the premier league are the ones attempting to stop this practice, so to call corruption when it is stopped by the clubs, most likely including us, seems a bit mad?
Toddacelli
User avatar
Posts: 1826
Karma: 1866

Re: Financial Fairplay Investigation - Further 2 points deducted.

Post

brap2 wrote: Tue Jun 11, 2024 4:20 pm Yeah but specifically in this case the premier league are the ones attempting to stop this practice, so to call corruption when it is stopped by the clubs, most likely including us, seems a bit mad?

Yep, yep, on the face of it 100%.

But let’s not forget that their attempts to ‘stop this practice’ included questionable and harsh sanctions on smaller, less lucrative clubs and nothing to larger clubs who bring more money into them.

So yeah, I’m sticking with corrupt.

I agree with you that our first job is to look at ourselves, but I’m not letting anyone else off the hook either.
Granite
Posts: 844
Karma: 391

Re: Financial Fairplay Investigation - Further 2 points deducted.

Post

Cozzie wrote: Tue Jun 11, 2024 3:22 pm Haven't heard or seen of anything similar about us yet.

Will be interesting to know whether or not we ourselves have to raise before the 1st of July or not, if at all. You'd think there would be murmurings of it by now.
I think it’s an absolute given.
superpull
Posts: 1325
Karma: 1131

Re: Financial Fairplay Investigation - Further 2 points deducted.

Post

Sorry, gecko option for the echo doesn't seem to be working anymore.

But a piece:
https://www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/sport/f ... e-29367967

For those that can't be arsed opening the site, the tl:dr is

- Swiss Ramble (https://swissramble.substack.com/p/whic ... fitability) crunched some numbers and thinks we can lose around £61m this last year without breaching.

- They also believe we are "a little bit over that".

- Onana has a remaining book value of £20m. A sale of £50m would represent sufficient profit to avoid a points deduction.
777Kidnappings
Posts: 3015
Karma: 1687

Re: Financial Fairplay Investigation - Further 2 points deducted.

Post

Genuine question why can't we just sell something to ourselves like Chelsea did. Surely everyone should be balancing their books like that now
Post Reply Previous topicNext topic