AjaxAndy wrote: ↑Fri Jan 10, 2025 5:16 pm
Wtf is this?
Read the room man, you can't be posting level headed comments like this on here right now. Quick call someone a cunt and redeem yourself, can be another poster, Dyche or Moyes... But this is a completely unacceptable post otherwise
So the point I’m seeing made, by Knutson and others who agree, is that the fullbacks and midfield are so poor that keeping things extremely tight and grinding out points is probably our optimal play for safety.
I can kind of see their point but something has just felt off about the way we’ve approached these matches. Maybe I am assigning the players more capability than they deserve, who knows.
Moyes is largely going to give us more of the same. Maybe being a new person gives the players a bit of a boost, maybe he’s got an additional idea or two about how to manufacture chances with this group of players.
Seems like we’ve chosen the safest way to freshen things up.
kramer wrote: ↑Fri Jan 10, 2025 8:44 pm
So the point I’m seeing made, by Knutson and others who agree, is that the fullbacks and midfield are so poor that keeping things extremely tight and grinding out points is probably our optimal play for safety.
I can kind of see their point but something has just felt off about the way we’ve approached these matches. Maybe I am assigning the players more capability than they deserve, who knows.
Moyes is largely going to give us more of the same. Maybe being a new person gives the players a bit of a boost, maybe he’s got an additional idea or two about how to manufacture chances with this group of players.
Seems like we’ve chosen the safest way to freshen things up.
Yeah I've been making that point for months, hope Moyes can find a way to resolve this without it leaving us open at the back... 3-4-3 and 3-4-2-1, 3-5-2 any of these would be a good start with McNeil or Harrison as LWB and Patterson as RWB.
Thing people are still seeing this squad through Dyche-tinted glasses. Not expecting Coleman and Baines standards but think the fullbacks and wingers will be much much brighter under Moyes.
kramer wrote: ↑Fri Jan 10, 2025 8:44 pm
So the point I’m seeing made, by Knutson and others who agree, is that the fullbacks and midfield are so poor that keeping things extremely tight and grinding out points is probably our optimal play for safety.
I can kind of see their point but something has just felt off about the way we’ve approached these matches. Maybe I am assigning the players more capability than they deserve, who knows.
Moyes is largely going to give us more of the same. Maybe being a new person gives the players a bit of a boost, maybe he’s got an additional idea or two about how to manufacture chances with this group of players.
Seems like we’ve chosen the safest way to freshen things up.
I think it's a bit chicken and egg personally. Are the fullbacks and midfield really that poor, or are they statistically poor because of the way they've been played etc?
Patterson certainly has potential to be an attacking full back, obviously it remains to be seen if he plays him and if he's defensively sound enough. I'd like to think that there's at least a degree of improvement possible across the board with even slightly more positive tactics and I certainly wouldn't blindly rely on stats without the context of who the manager is and what his methods are.
Risky wrote: ↑Fri Jan 10, 2025 9:02 pm
I think it's a bit chicken and egg personally. Are the fullbacks and midfield really that poor, or are they statistically poor because of the way they've been played etc?
Patterson certainly has potential to be an attacking full back, obviously it remains to be seen if he plays him and if he's defensively sound enough. I'd like to think that there's at least a degree of improvement possible across the board with even slightly more positive tactics and I certainly wouldn't blindly rely on stats without the context of who the manager is and what his methods are.
Young is, he's been really solid this season but his inability to overlap and get back means we end up with him crossing from deep or the RW being doubled up constantly by 2 defenders.
Myko overlaps but is horrible at crossing so we need to remove both ideally and play Patterson and McNeil as wing backs.
So yeah it's both, Dyche's persistence with Young affected so much of our play at both ends, and Myko is just crap.
Patterson looks a footballer and definitely the best of the crop going forward but he frightens me in a back 4. He just isn't now, and I don't think he will be, defensively sound enough. His positioning just looks wrong. With a strong back 3, he could definitely work but I just don't think he's a full back.
In a world full of adversity, we must still dare to dream.