James Garner
- Toddacelli
- Posts: 1971
- Karma: 1997
-
Free Agent
- Posts: 1166
- Karma: 439
Re: James Garner
Still think he's performed very well thus far this season and has been a huge reason we are doing well.
-
StirlingBlue
- Posts: 1802
- Karma: 930
Re: James Garner
https://www.reddit.com/r/Everton/s/uT7VWnG5fU
So funny to see how Garner is viewed by other parts of the fanbase vs here
So funny to see how Garner is viewed by other parts of the fanbase vs here
Re: James Garner
Everton reddit was also massively in favour of Lampard and Dyche even towards the end so you know...
Re: James Garner
Garner has had a very good season and his strength is in being a versatile player. Good player to have in the squad, not someone I see bossing it for Arsenal one day.
Re: James Garner
Don’t really disagree with anything there.
Think everyone agrees that he’s an important part of the squad and needs a new contract.
The disagreement comes with the level people think he can play at.
I think he’s an average premier league midfielder who’ll struggle to play for a club better than us.
Others think hes a lot better than that.
Don’t see it myself but we absolutely need to give him a new deal.
Think everyone agrees that he’s an important part of the squad and needs a new contract.
The disagreement comes with the level people think he can play at.
I think he’s an average premier league midfielder who’ll struggle to play for a club better than us.
Others think hes a lot better than that.
Don’t see it myself but we absolutely need to give him a new deal.
Re: James Garner
Some people definitely see him as worse than that, but I agree with your assessment of him as a player... Average player but good to have around and you know what you're going to get from him pretty much week in week out.TheRam wrote: ↑Mon Dec 08, 2025 7:57 pm Don’t really disagree with anything there.
Think everyone agrees that he’s an important part of the squad and needs a new contract.
The disagreement comes with the level people think he can play at.
I think he’s an average premier league midfielder who’ll struggle to play for a club better than us.
Others think hes a lot better than that.
Don’t see it myself but we absolutely need to give him a new deal.
Re: James Garner
Really don’t get this Kopite hatred thing ? Lots of players supported clubs other than the one they currently play for, think he said he grew up in a red family,what's he supposed to do about that ?
Re: James Garner
Thank goodness !StirlingBlue wrote: ↑Mon Dec 08, 2025 6:29 pm https://www.reddit.com/r/Everton/s/uT7VWnG5fU
So funny to see how Garner is viewed by other parts of the fanbase vs here
Re: James Garner
Yeah think it's a it weird people care about this kind of thing. You get one career as a footballer, your club loyalties don't matter as long as you're giving your all on the field.