Man City found guilty of 114 charges

Chat about football that isn't Everton in here
Posts: 8546
Joined: Thu Oct 26, 2023 4:44 pm
Location: Wherever I lay my hat
Karma: 3453

Re: Man City found guilty of 114 charges

Post

Lazarou II wrote: Fri Oct 02, 2026 11:15 am If they could prove their innocence would it not have been in everyone's interest to submit that while it was being investigated?
Or this apparent "irrefutable evidence" that could have cleared them in the first place.
Posts: 7686
Joined: Fri Oct 27, 2023 11:28 am
Karma: 3892

Re: Man City found guilty of 114 charges

Post

I only caught a bit of this on the radio, but it sounded like their argument was that it's all fine because all the sponsors are owned by ADUG, so it doesn't matter where the money came from?

Is that right or did I not get the full jist?
Posts: 5635
Joined: Sun Oct 29, 2023 1:10 pm
Karma: 7004

Re: Man City found guilty of 114 charges

Post

AjaxAndy wrote: Fri Oct 02, 2026 2:44 pm I only caught a bit of this on the radio, but it sounded like their argument was that it's all fine because all the sponsors are owned by ADUG, so it doesn't matter where the money came from?

Is that right or did I not get the full jist?
As I understand it, City's argument appears to be that the wildly inflated sponsorship deals on their books aren't paid by their owners, but by a variety of companies in Abu Dhabi, and that those companies just happen to regularly apply to the Abu Dhabi government for funding, as a totally separate series of arrangements.

There is one small problem with that. The argument was already repeatedly presented by City in the initial hearing, and was dismissed out of hand by the three senior legal bods on the independent panel. In fact it was demonstrated by the panel that they knowingly lied about that, and a number of the witnesses they presented were found to be lying in their testimonies.

The more legalistic people appearing on various podcasts this week are suggesting if that is the crux of City's argument in the appeal, then they'll get short shrift and they might even be viewed more harshly for effectively ''wasting the court's time''. The appeal isn't there to retread old arguments, and arguments already presented and judged upon. It's there for serious breaches of protocol or serious legal errors in the initial hearing.

I think a couple of things are happening with the City owners. I think they are in denial, because they're not used to being held to account by anyone or anything. They tone of their responses suggests that they are almost offended by the idea of having to explain or justify themselves.

And then I think the consequences of a heavy punishment are so devastating for the club and the reputation of the owners that they've almost decided to double down and say ''fuck it, we might as well go down swinging''. It's almost like the desperation when someone who murders someone, goes on the run and ends up killing other people in an attempt to escape because they're already fucked.

Unfortunately their tone deaf media comments appear to be gaslighting the vast majority of the City fanbase into some MAGA-like entrenchment and collective delusion, where they are defending the owners despite all of the evidence and they are veering into a conspiratorial mindset about ''people out to get them''. Maybe that will ease over time, as the realisations set in.
Posts: 7686
Joined: Fri Oct 27, 2023 11:28 am
Karma: 3892

Re: Man City found guilty of 114 charges

Post

Bluedylan1 wrote: Fri Oct 02, 2026 4:54 pm As I understand it, City's argument appears to be that the wildly inflated sponsorship deals on their books aren't paid by their owners, but by a variety of companies in Abu Dhabi, and that those companies just happen to regularly apply to the Abu Dhabi government for funding, as a totally separate series of arrangements.

There is one small problem with that. The argument was already repeatedly presented by City in the initial hearing, and was dismissed out of hand by the three senior legal bods on the independent panel. In fact it was demonstrated by the panel that they knowingly lied about that, and a number of the witnesses they presented were found to be lying in their testimonies.

The more legalistic people appearing on various podcasts this week are suggesting if that is the crux of City's argument in the appeal, then they'll get short shrift and they might even be viewed more harshly for effectively ''wasting the court's time''. The appeal isn't there to retread old arguments, and arguments already presented and judged upon. It's there for serious breaches of protocol or serious legal errors in the initial hearing.

I think a couple of things are happening with the City owners. I think they are in denial, because they're not used to being held to account by anyone or anything. They tone of their responses suggests that they are almost offended by the idea of having to explain or justify themselves.

And then I think the consequences of a heavy punishment are so devastating for the club and the reputation of the owners that they've almost decided to double down and say ''fuck it, we might as well go down swinging''. It's almost like the desperation when someone who murders someone, goes on the run and ends up killing other people in an attempt to escape because they're already fucked.

Unfortunately their tone deaf media comments appear to be gaslighting the vast majority of the City fanbase into some MAGA-like entrenchment and collective delusion, where they are defending the owners despite all of the evidence and they are veering into a conspiratorial mindset about ''people out to get them''. Maybe that will ease over time, as the realisations set in.
Thanks mate, great summary 👍
Posts: 1218
Joined: Fri Jun 14, 2024 7:27 pm
Karma: 626

Re: Man City found guilty of 114 charges

Post

I'm expecting a lot of tough talk now and not much action. The premier League will come under immense political pressure to 'do the right thing'.
Burnhams comments about it being a great shame if they sold up typifies it, they've helped bankroll the Manchester he likes to harp on about and they have already inferred that they will look at their investment strategies in the the UK if the punishment is too harsh.
Think this has the potential to kill football as we know it, and this is something the premier league has encouraged by these state ownerships.
Posts: 16145
Joined: Thu Oct 26, 2023 6:37 pm
Karma: 13235

Re: Man City found guilty of 114 charges

Post

Just read bluemoon forum. The victimhood is insane. Maybe any set of fans would be the same but it's wild.
Posts: 9612
Joined: Thu Oct 26, 2023 4:42 pm
Karma: 10036

Re: Man City found guilty of 114 charges

Post

This whole thing is grim beyond belief.

The game has absolutely gone.

A clubs owners threatening our actual government.

And people still think PSR is the main problem.
Posts: 7686
Joined: Fri Oct 27, 2023 11:28 am
Karma: 3892

Re: Man City found guilty of 114 charges

Post

Shogun wrote: Fri Oct 02, 2026 8:22 pm Just read bluemoon forum. The victimhood is insane. Maybe any set of fans would be the same but it's wild.
I read one poster say something along the following that got loads of likes...

'because the premier league didn't penalise us at the time, it's unfair to retrospectively do so now. If you were caught speeding 115 times over a 10 year period, and they didn't penalise you, but then decided to issue all your tickets in one go, they didn't give you chance to reform. So if they'd penalised us previously we would have been able to reform and subsequent breaches wouldn't have happened'.

I really wanted to join just to explain that if you murdered 115 people over a decade, and they charged you with them all that the same time, you couldn't argue that if they'd arrested you after the first, you wouldn't have murdered all the other people after 😂
Posts: 16145
Joined: Thu Oct 26, 2023 6:37 pm
Karma: 13235

Re: Man City found guilty of 114 charges

Post

TheRam wrote: Fri Oct 02, 2026 8:52 pm A clubs owners threatening our actual government.
According to Bluemoon, they're pulling out their investment because the Premier League and UK are dragging their name through the mud unfairly...

I just can't imagine Everton being owned by a middle eastern country and us being so overwhelmingly supportive of them.

I think I'd understand it more if they were focused on the incompetence and inconsistency of the Premier League which would be valid but the sportswashing is crazy. Mad what a few titles can do.
Posts: 797
Joined: Fri Oct 27, 2023 12:44 pm
Karma: 638

Re: Man City found guilty of 114 charges

Post

Reasonable chance this becomes existential for City.

I think them threatening to withdraw investment from the UK could backfire and push the Prem to expel them and the EFL to reject any application.

If the plan is to play big dick it is hugely risky and will turn everyone against them.
Posts: 2274
Joined: Thu Oct 26, 2023 5:02 pm
Karma: 1337

Re: Man City found guilty of 114 charges

Post

Appreciate this had been covered a million times over but I found this a very relaxing content piece

Posts: 10374
Joined: Fri Oct 27, 2023 7:40 am
Location: 53.4389° N - 2.9662° W
Karma: 4275

Re: Man City found guilty of 114 charges

Post

That's fantastic!
Posts: 4527
Joined: Fri Oct 27, 2023 7:11 am
Karma: 1705

Re: Man City found guilty of 114 charges

Post

https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/ar ... w9w451vx8o

We’ll be getting a points deduction for accepting so much of their dirty money :whistle:
Posts: 772
Joined: Sat Oct 28, 2023 6:38 am
Karma: 326

Re: Man City found guilty of 114 charges

Post

I was initially doubtful that they would be punished severely but now it definitely seems to be gathering momentum that there will be serious repercussions, not only that but this doesn't even cover 2018-26 where a lot of these issues must have continued. Could it even end with the current Man City football club being liquidated if it is beyond tainted?

Imagine being a Man City fan who'd been around to see Michael Ball looking dejected after being hammered 8-1 against Middlesbrough, and having grown up in an era where the GOAT for them meant Shaun Goater and placing a lot of hope on Michael Johnson being the next best thing. It must still feel a little surreal seeing all the success they've had since 2008 and signing the likes of Robinho, Aguero, David Silva, Erling Haaland, Kevin de Bruyne, Bernardo Silva and Rodri. And this could be null and void.
Double champ
Double champ
Posts: 4648
Joined: Thu Oct 26, 2023 7:03 pm
Location: 33°51'06.5"S 151°13'06.6"E
Karma: 1802

Re: Man City found guilty of 114 charges

Post

One of the punishments, assuming there isn't a concrete chunk of irrefutable evidence to prove their innocence - or in fact just as a matter of proper process - should be that to allow them to continue as a footballing entity they must open all their financial records and communications SINCE the Northern Hemisphere winter of 2018 to the League.

There would be no reason, particularly given how bullish they still seem to be, to suggest that their alleged dodgy revenue inflation, and expense minimisation practices ceased in 2018.

There must be a better than a coin flip's chance that they're still actually doing it.

So, yes let's look at that first 9 years uncovered by Pinto and Der Spiegel, but also let's not use the 'lack of evidence handed to us on a plate' excuse, and actually go further, a full audit and internal review - perhaps this is something the new football regulator could organise.

They must have won, what 15-20 titles/cups since that not only would have been made possible through the known era of cheating, but that its highly likely that the practices continued, further contributing to their largest period of success.

If guilty they should be stripped of everything they've won since the dodgy practices began.
Post Reply Previous topicNext topic