Man City found guilty of 114 charges
- Posts: 1307
- Joined: Fri Oct 27, 2023 7:59 am
- Karma: 307
Re: Man City found guilty of 114 charges
City have created a new genre or movement in modern football
they have become the very first Existentalists
all their irrefutable evidence only exists in their conscience - in the ether but sadly not in the real world
we can call this Existensalism similar to the art genres in the early 20th century - surrealism fauvism realism futurism impressionism post impressionism......and the one that is more closely linked to city is the surrealists - exploring the subconcious creating dream imagery often resulting in the depiction of illogical or dreamlike scenes or ideas
they have become the very first Existentalists
all their irrefutable evidence only exists in their conscience - in the ether but sadly not in the real world
we can call this Existensalism similar to the art genres in the early 20th century - surrealism fauvism realism futurism impressionism post impressionism......and the one that is more closely linked to city is the surrealists - exploring the subconcious creating dream imagery often resulting in the depiction of illogical or dreamlike scenes or ideas
- Posts: 7686
- Joined: Fri Oct 27, 2023 11:28 am
- Karma: 3892
Re: Man City found guilty of 114 charges
Had my daily read of Blue Moon this morning, and it's insane how they seem to genuinely believe (or are in complete denial) that the club have done nothing wrong.Evertonfc15 wrote: Sat Oct 03, 2026 8:00 am City have created a new genre or movement in modern football
they have become the very first Existentalists
all their irrefutable evidence only exists in their conscience - in the ether but sadly not in the real world
we can call this Existensalism similar to the art genres in the early 20th century - surrealism fauvism realism futurism impressionism post impressionism......and the one that is more closely linked to city is the surrealists - exploring the subconcious creating dream imagery often resulting in the depiction of illogical or dreamlike scenes or ideas
Forget the numerous emails where they talk about what they're doing, the insurmountable evidence that confirms it... It's all made up, and City can prove it.
Or it's all part of the 'cartel' which for some reason they not only believe they aren't part of, but also fail to see that if they were let off for cheating by £900m (plus whatever has occurred since 2018) it would make them the king pins of the cartel.
And finally it doesn't matter if they've cheated because the economic impact on the country if the UAE pull funding is too impactful for sporting rules to apply anyway.
It would be easy to feel sorry for fans who've not had any say in what their club have done, regardless of the success they've enjoyed... But the way they try and justify what's gone on, and believe they're above the law, just demolishes any sympathy anyone should or could have for them.
- Posts: 1307
- Joined: Fri Oct 27, 2023 7:59 am
- Karma: 307
Re: Man City found guilty of 114 charges
true......and some not all city fans that have appeared on talksport - 606 they are literally hysterical
they are shouting down the phone to the presenters and glossing over the reality the facts the truth
tbh am finding it quite amusing now
the presenter is just explaining the facts and the city callers just ignore him/her and just start shouting down the phone
its embarrasing
they are shouting down the phone to the presenters and glossing over the reality the facts the truth
tbh am finding it quite amusing now
the presenter is just explaining the facts and the city callers just ignore him/her and just start shouting down the phone
its embarrasing
- Posts: 3124
- Joined: Fri Oct 27, 2023 2:00 am
- Location: California Love
- Karma: 1241
Re: Man City found guilty of 114 charges
Cereal Killer wrote: Fri Oct 02, 2026 10:44 pm https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/ar ... w9w451vx8o
We’ll be getting a points deduction for accepting so much of their dirty money![]()
- Posts: 5295
- Joined: Thu Oct 26, 2023 7:36 pm
- Karma: 2108
Re: Man City found guilty of 114 charges
I've said my bit about this, but I do think having parallel conversations that don't include the financial rules be they FFP/PSR/SCR or whatever is missing the point and either invites in time more attempts at bending of the rules or a complete hegemony by certain teams.TheRam wrote: Fri Oct 02, 2026 8:52 pm This whole thing is grim beyond belief.
The game has absolutely gone.
A clubs owners threatening our actual government.
And people still think PSR is the main problem.
Man City used their power and money to break the rules because they wanted to have sustained success and win the biggest prizes (for whatever reason, likely heavily in part for sportswashing).
That's bad, agreed. However, I don't think it's much different to clubs like Man United, Arsenal, etc using their power, money and historical standing in the game to seemingly backchannel and pressurise Platini back in the day at UEFA and Richard Scudamore for the Premier League to encase their advantage in cement which for me is basically being given an officially sanctioned huge advantage which if you were cynically looking at it could also be described as cheating. In 2010 when they formed the big boy European Club Association and met in Manchester and were as Platini said himself pressuring them to put these limits on clubs with the obvious outcome being limiting the ability of other clubs who wanted to compete to be able to do so. Following that there was the "gang of four" (Man United, Arsenal, Liverpool and Tottenham) wrote to the PL to say they'd go over their heads if they didn't implement their idea for these rules.
I genuinely think it's pretty much as bad that these clubs can set the rules to what they want effectively in order to cement their fortunes, never mind even that wasn't enough eventually with the whole Super League of it all, as a club that looks to break those rules to win themselves. One thing tries to subvert these rules to their own end and the others make the rules for their own ends.
It's entirely part of the same conversation. None of those clubs should be the ones leading the governing bodies by the nose. Every club in the PL should have a reasonable chance to win the competition in a fan's lifetime, that is a what an actually fair and competitive league could and should be able to achieve.
- Posts: 7686
- Joined: Fri Oct 27, 2023 11:28 am
- Karma: 3892
Re: Man City found guilty of 114 charges
No anger in the slightest towards the owners from me. Its quite simple,theyre fighting made up rules to keep the teams that were at the top,constantly at the top. Myself im completely grateful and proud of everything they've done for my team and the surrounding area. Quite simple really,if you look at it without desperate, bias,cartel driven eyes and theres not a team in all four divisions that wouldnt have welcomed it !
- from Blue Moon
I just can't understand the blindness of their fans. Do they not realise that the rules they completely and deliberately disregarded for a decade (and likely 8 years more), are also the same rules that have cemented them as the dominant force in the division whilst other teams have to decemate their squads the moment they break in to the top 4 to comply with those rules.
They're fast becoming the worst fan base in football.
- from Blue Moon
I just can't understand the blindness of their fans. Do they not realise that the rules they completely and deliberately disregarded for a decade (and likely 8 years more), are also the same rules that have cemented them as the dominant force in the division whilst other teams have to decemate their squads the moment they break in to the top 4 to comply with those rules.
They're fast becoming the worst fan base in football.
- Posts: 16145
- Joined: Thu Oct 26, 2023 6:37 pm
- Karma: 13235
Re: Man City found guilty of 114 charges
Did say on the news last night "Man City broke the rules which meant they could spend £100 millions more than they should have been able which gave them a significant sporting advantage"
What advantage did they have over Arsenal, United and Liverpool?
What advantage did they have over Arsenal, United and Liverpool?
- Posts: 1307
- Joined: Fri Oct 27, 2023 7:59 am
- Karma: 307
Re: Man City found guilty of 114 charges
.......and take rugby league eg wakefield win their first super league - how fantastic was thatblueToffee wrote: Sat Oct 03, 2026 8:43 pm I've said my bit about this, but I do think having parallel conversations that don't include the financial rules be they FFP/PSR/SCR or whatever is missing the point and either invites in time more attempts at bending of the rules or a complete hegemony by certain teams.
Man City used their power and money to break the rules because they wanted to have sustained success and win the biggest prizes (for whatever reason, likely heavily in part for sportswashing).
That's bad, agreed. However, I don't think it's much different to clubs like Man United, Arsenal, etc using their power, money and historical standing in the game to seemingly backchannel and pressurise Platini back in the day at UEFA and Richard Scudamore for the Premier League to encase their advantage in cement which for me is basically being given an officially sanctioned huge advantage which if you were cynically looking at it could also be described as cheating. In 2010 when they formed the big boy European Club Association and met in Manchester and were as Platini said himself pressuring them to put these limits on clubs with the obvious outcome being limiting the ability of other clubs who wanted to compete to be able to do so. Following that there was the "gang of four" (Man United, Arsenal, Liverpool and Tottenham) wrote to the PL to say they'd go over their heads if they didn't implement their idea for these rules.
I genuinely think it's pretty much as bad that these clubs can set the rules to what they want effectively in order to cement their fortunes, never mind even that wasn't enough eventually with the whole Super League of it all, as a club that looks to break those rules to win themselves. One thing tries to subvert these rules to their own end and the others make the rules for their own ends.
It's entirely part of the same conversation. None of those clubs should be the ones leading the governing bodies by the nose. Every club in the PL should have a reasonable chance to win the competition in a fan's lifetime, that is a what an actually fair and competitive league could and should be able to achieve.
those fans realising a lifetimes dream ambition great to witness this
pity the prem league cannot mirror the rugby league the way its run every team has a chance if they get their team- manager tactics right - NOT dependent on committing mass fraud on an industrial scale
- Posts: 7686
- Joined: Fri Oct 27, 2023 11:28 am
- Karma: 3892
Re: Man City found guilty of 114 charges
Whilst that's true, and the rules are obviously awful for competition, it's still not an excuse or a get out for flagrant cheating.Shogun wrote: Sun Oct 04, 2026 8:09 am Did say on the news last night "Man City broke the rules which meant they could spend £100 millions more than they should have been able which gave them a significant sporting advantage"
What advantage did they have over Arsenal, United and Liverpool?
Sit also doesn't account for teams like Villa having to sell their best players the moment they start to see some success so as to comply with the rules.
The rules being fit for purpose, and City breaking and hiding their breaking of the rules are two very separate arguments.
- Posts: 2368
- Joined: Thu Oct 26, 2023 8:27 pm
- Location: Manchester
- Karma: 1439
Re: Man City found guilty of 114 charges
Not at all. They are recycling the same defence with the same arguments. All information pertaining to the case had to be revealed and submitted during the initial 12 week hearing.Lazarou II wrote: Fri Oct 02, 2026 12:18 pm I assumed that to launch an appeal you'd need bring new evidence to light, so they can just recycle the same defence?
They are simply switching the Judeans Peoples Front argument with the Peoples Front of Judea argument, neither of which are as effective as the Chewbacca Theory.
Hearing arguments that expelling City might push close towards a Super League, and that once the anger dies, the Premier League may not want or be able to make the commercial decisions that the charges would surely require, and would be executed had the club being a club like, for instance, Everton.
Just another piece of evidence why the commercial entity shouldn't be the regulator.
- Posts: 4527
- Joined: Fri Oct 27, 2023 7:11 am
- Karma: 1705
Re: Man City found guilty of 114 charges
Some clubs want retrospective points deductions applied to the cheating seasons, then compensation paid based on where City would have finished
Basically knock off about 20-30 points a season, drop them to 5th/6th, and generally only the rest of the “big 6” will get any compensation
- Posts: 4335
- Joined: Fri Oct 27, 2023 8:12 am
- Karma: 1449
Re: Man City found guilty of 114 charges
Surprised that Infantino hasn’t expressed an opinion as head of FIFA, maybe he will give the Sheik a peace prize and it will Al be sorted.
- Posts: 1218
- Joined: Fri Jun 14, 2024 7:27 pm
- Karma: 626
Re: Man City found guilty of 114 charges
That'd be significant for us. We would've possibly finished in Europe or the Champions League on a few occasions. If that were the case would we have had the financial difficulties we did (probably cause we were clueless under Moshiri), will the league then have to redacted the points deduction, will Burnley then not have a case against us, will we get our lost prize money back due to points deductions, etc, etc, etcCereal Killer wrote: Tue Oct 06, 2026 7:57 pm![]()
Some clubs want retrospective points deductions applied to the cheating seasons, then compensation paid based on where City would have finished
Basically knock off about 20-30 points a season, drop them to 5th/6th, and generally only the rest of the “big 6” will get any compensation
![]()
![]()
- Posts: 10374
- Joined: Fri Oct 27, 2023 7:40 am
- Location: 53.4389° N - 2.9662° W
- Karma: 4275
- Posts: 16145
- Joined: Thu Oct 26, 2023 6:37 pm
- Karma: 13235
Re: Man City found guilty of 114 charges
Burnham was right though. And this is what happens and the price you pay when you let (especially sportswashing) countries own football clubs.
If they get sent to league two/non-league then the UAE are going to leave and there's not much point in then keeping their other investments in the country at that point.
If they get sent to league two/non-league then the UAE are going to leave and there's not much point in then keeping their other investments in the country at that point.