I just mean that to me they make no sense, don’t mean anything, other people may take them as scientifically proven.TheRam wrote: Thu Nov 19, 2026 7:01 pm Do you think these stats are made up, or don’t mean anything?
Tyrique George
- Posts: 4335
- Joined: Fri Oct 27, 2023 8:12 am
- Karma: 1449
Re: Tyrique George
- Double champ

- Posts: 4649
- Joined: Thu Oct 26, 2023 7:03 pm
- Location: 33°51'06.5"S 151°13'06.6"E
- Karma: 1803
Re: Tyrique George
It's promising and I like him a lot, but of the dozen players in the league that are both 20 or younger and have played at least 50% of available minutes, there's only around half of those that play in an position likely to go on a run, and Harrison Armstrong is one of them.
I think the sample size that meets the requirements is far too small to be highlighting Tyrique's output. Even with his relatively high number of dribbles, his success rate was barely 50%.
- Posts: 1816
- Joined: Thu Oct 26, 2023 5:09 pm
- Karma: 1633
Re: Tyrique George
I mean, it depends on what you call "scientifically", but they are definitely "proven".Escalator wrote: Thu Nov 19, 2026 10:04 pm I just mean that to me they make no sense, don’t mean anything, other people may take them as scientifically proven.
Somebody has watched the game and counted how many times a player has been in control of the ball and either beat a man or created a chance. Nothing more, nothing less.
There's no guess work - Player X has created a chance Y amount of times.
Now, a player with high numbers in both is in a certain part of the grid. Players with one OR the other are in another and players with neither are in the 4th quadrant.
I wish people would stop using their own deficiencies in GCSE level maths as some stick to beat stats with. (not accusing anybody specifically, just a broad assumption i am making - unlike the makers of these graphs)
- Posts: 1538
- Joined: Sat Sep 20, 2025 12:31 pm
- Karma: 912
Re: Tyrique George
Statistics based on verifiable evidence kind of are scientifically proven though.Escalator wrote: Thu Nov 19, 2026 10:04 pm I just mean that to me they make no sense, don’t mean anything, other people may take them as scientifically proven.
- Double champ

- Posts: 4649
- Joined: Thu Oct 26, 2023 7:03 pm
- Location: 33°51'06.5"S 151°13'06.6"E
- Karma: 1803
Re: Tyrique George
(Broad point from me too, but just to differentiate it from others...)superpull wrote: Fri Nov 20, 2026 1:56 pm I mean, it depends on what you call "scientifically", but they are definitely "proven".
Somebody has watched the game and counted how many times a player has been in control of the ball and either beat a man or created a chance. Nothing more, nothing less.
There's no guess work - Player X has created a chance Y amount of times.
Now, a player with high numbers in both is in a certain part of the grid. Players with one OR the other are in another and players with neither are in the 4th quadrant.
I wish people would stop using their own deficiencies in GCSE level maths as some stick to beat stats with. (not accusing anybody specifically, just a broad assumption i am making - unlike the makers of these graphs)
Just taking this Tyrique example, I think it's very much valid to question why it would be decided to highlight 'how many dribbles a particular player makes', and label it the 'most in the league' for the certain criteria, when there are only 11 other players in the league that actually fit the specific criteria, based on their position only 4 that are likely to attempt dribbles regularly, and of those, only one other, Rayan, has played barely comparable minutes.
The next player, Alysson Edward, has only played a third of the time Rayan has. How could those two even really have comparable absolute stats? Wouldn't pro-rata be a better measure?
The problem is not only in design, but that this information is often 'run with' as some kind of proof to back up other's claims/ biases, when it doesn't. No one does the work to see what the sample size is, which highlights the lack of solid conclusion that can be drawn.
Of the 466 players who have played so far this season, this data related to and measures only 3 players of any relevance. It compares less than 1% of the league. If they put that information in their post it would be more honest and accurate, but for Opta in this case, rightly take away some of the wow factor.
No one doubts that the numbers are actually 'right', many rightly doubt how important, reliable and meaningful they are.