If you could bring back a Moyes player in their prime, who would it be?

[Stumpy]

For a one off pick it has to be Baines.
However our desperation for goals i'd go for Yak or Rooney

[Silas]

Fernandes was wank.

Cahill would work well in this side, Baines as well but Arteta would be amazing alongside Gueye

[kramer]

Fun question: how would everyone choose to deploy an Arteta in this team?

Obviously, his very best form was as a proper deep central playmaker BUT you could make the argument that we’re stronger there than on the right and he was also bossing games at times as Beckham-style right midfielder. Still get chills when I see the Fiorentina goal.

[Silas]

Absolutely through the middle, loved him in central midfield

[Jamokachi]

For this team, as others have said, I think Cahill would have the biggest influence. His goals from midfield would be massive for us. He proved he was pivotal in Moyes' early (not so great) and later (really good squad) sides, so you know he'd be massive for this side.

[777Kidnappings]

Who cares what he did/didn’t do for anyone else….there could be a number of reasons he “didn’t do much” elsewhere the same as players who come to us don’t do much when they come…..
Silly analogy….

He didn't do much at Everton either. He didn't do much anywhere

[Bob Sacamano]

Baines

[sam of the south]

17 year-old Rooney coming through now, with us soon to be out of the financial woods, new rich owners, new stadium.

Crikey, timing is everything isn’t it.

[brap2]

It's from Baines, Fellaini, Rooney, Arteta, and Yakubu

[Toddacelli]

Yakubu

All others would improve us in their areas of the pitch, but Yakubu would add points to the board by scoring goals to win and draw games.

[superpull]

Mad we've got to page 4 with a solitary Coleman shout

[Trowel]

Lescott in his prime is worth a mention. But Cahill for me

[Shogun]

Speaking of Lescott, was watching Everton v Larissa highlights the other they and had a giggle at their goal

[Toddacelli]

Big Vic - but only for European games

[toffee_scot]

I’m not sure Yakubu even at his prime would work well in this current team especially considering our problems getting the ball forward to create chances for the strikers.

No doubt he was a good goal scorer back in the day but when the players under Moyes were not playing great he was a bit redundant with Anichebe sometimes offering more.