The NSNO Everton Forums

Big Nevs Vaz wrote: ↑Sun Jul 06, 2025 7:01 pm Part of the frustration is in the hope of the new stadium, new owners, a chance to reset and then we are looking at a squad with some old names that really should not be there. Giving Seamus a playing contract is a bit daft as well. He can’t seem to warm up at this point without injuring himself. I get it can’t all be done at once but Moyes is proving again that his default is to be risk averse. Why not bring in a younger lad with potential and spend the wages there. We have 3 other centre backs.

Some continuity when moving into a new environment is not a bad thing, let’s discuss after Christmas

Escalator wrote: ↑Sun Jul 06, 2025 6:19 pm I’m pretty sure he knows exactly what to expect of Keane and feels that he has a role to play, you don’t get to Moyes level without knowing a little bit about football, there are also other people on the staff that will have seen enough of Keane’s performance to have had some input into the decision.

I’m sure Seamus and Bainsey have told him exactly how it is.

Bluebridge wrote: ↑Sun Jul 06, 2025 8:23 pm I’m sure Seamus and Bainsey have told him exactly how it is.

Exactly !

Not worth worrying about. He's backup, the manager trusts him for the role, he's a cheaper option than buying new... all make perfect sense when you think about how many new additions we need to bring in. I think it's a sensible if uninspiring decision.

Can’t believe this argument is still going on

He will have taken a wage cut, but yes we don’t know how big
We can’t overspend because while we are sort of out of PSR woods it’s not there yet
We have other priorities

And the biggest point is simply that, while there’s this back and forth over whether or not it does or doesn’t matter who is 4th choice CB and whether or not he will play much, the simple fact is even first choice CBs make mistakes at top sides. The idea that we could and should have got a 4th choice CB who will apparently make NO mistakes, is for the birds. You could get a guy who will deliver less mistakes, but they will cost a fee, and the “less mistakes” will be unknown.

Keane has a mistake in him, no doubt, and he frustrates me as much as anyone else, but he’s decent at 4th choice (at least as much as any one else we could have got), and keeping him doesn’t cost us a fee we need to spend elsewhere

It’s simple. Both things are true in that it’s not what anyone “wants”, but also it’s logical.

Plot twist.

He’s impressed Moyes so much in training he’s now first choice.

sam of the south wrote: ↑Mon Jul 07, 2025 6:57 am Plot twist.

He’s impressed Moyes so much in training he’s now first choice.

Every other manager we have had since Keane has been here has tried and failed to revive him moyes might as well give it a go

I have got over the decision and the initial outrage, which will only come back if he starts at centre half over O’Brien

Our best defender tonight.

That touch under pressure was

He'll have a brain fart at some point but let's make the most of it because when he's good he's good.

Kind of wild to watch him oscillate between absolute fucking rock and walking calamity with no middle ground ever observed.

One of the strangest players I can remember for crazy swings in form.

Is that 4 or 5 games now under Moyes?

Been great in all of them, very quietly going about his business and looking our best defender at the moment.

Yes we know the wheels could come off at any moment, but he's looking good right now and I don't think anyone could complain about him resigning for this year at present.

Yeah fair play to the lad

I feel sorry for him, he's been really good again but you know that the slightest fuck up and there will be a massive pile on as usual, even if it doesn't lead to a goal. Plays like Tarks has these first couple of games and this thread would be on page 30.