The NSNO Everton Forums

Worrying thing is when was the last good transfer before Ndiaye?

Onana?

Yeah fair point. Before that?

I reckon that particular window under Silva was really good.

Richarlison, Digne, Mina, Zouma.

Give anything for that sort of quality now.

Gana has been a brilliant signing.

Time will tell but I think Chermiti will prove a good signing.

McNeil has been key. Garner has been key. Tarkowski has been key, they were all in the same window.

Credit to Thelwell for this one I think. Wanted him at Sheff U, when he went to Marseille and saw a chance to go back in for him after a rough season in France, for a very reasonable fee.

N'Diaye, great
Iroegbunam, good
O'Brien, TBA

I've seen worse transfer windows. Future windows are key, if our strike rates continue to improve as it has in recent windows, and with actual cash to spend, then I'm not that worried.

Jury's out on iroegbuenam surely

brap2 wrote: ↑Mon Oct 21, 2024 12:31 pm Jury's out on iroegbuenam surely

he is still a young lad, he has shown some great ability but he is no where near finished and some areas need improving but as he was basicly a ffp signing i didnt expect anything from him

brap2 wrote: ↑Mon Oct 21, 2024 12:31 pm Jury's out on iroegbuenam surely

he is still a young lad, he has shown some great ability but he is no where near finished and some areas need improving but as he was basicly a ffp signing i didnt expect anything from him

brap2 wrote: ↑Mon Oct 21, 2024 12:31 pm Jury's out on iroegbuenam surely

As an investment, and at that price, I think he's already shown enough to be a good acquisition.

I think we can accommodate him better in the middle with team selection and horses for courses, than when we had no other option than to play him and leave him a bit exposed.

Right so we can't really be praising him as a good signing yet surely

This isn't particularly a dig at Dyche, but I would like to see Iroegbunam under a manager that want to play football more. I do think there's plenty to work with.

brap2 wrote: ↑Mon Oct 21, 2024 1:11 pm Right so we can't really be praising him as a good signing yet surely

No, but he was a free signing really and looks a decent enough player to be worth having around the squad.